breakup heartbreak healing

When the Breakup Hits Twice: Realising You Loved Someone Who Never Existed

Breakups already feel like your brain is staging a hostile takeover. One minute you’re doom-scrolling while eating ice cream straight from the tub, the next you’re lying on the floor questioning the meaning of socks. But there’s a special kind of heartbreak that neuroscience has a lot to say about: when you realise not only did you lose someone, but that the person you thought you loved was never really there…When the Breakup Hits Twice.

Yep. The “phantom partner.” The ghost of who we believed they were. And when reality crashes in, it feels doubly devastating.


The Brain, the Illusionist

Here’s the thing: your brain is less of a truth-machine and more of a creative director with an overactive imagination.

  • Neuroscience 101: The prefrontal cortex (your rational planner) teams up with the limbic system (your emotional hype squad) and basically runs a Photoshop operation. You notice small details you like, filter out red flags, and then—ta-da!—your brain builds a mental avatar of your partner.
  • This avatar is who you fall in love with. Not them exactly. Your brain’s curated, idealised edition of them.

This is why, when you discover the betrayal, mismatch, or harsh reality, it’s like a double-breakup: one with the real person, and one with the brain’s handcrafted illusion. Ouch.


Why the Breakup Hurts So Much

  1. Dopamine Withdrawal
    Falling in love lights up the brain like a pinball machine. Dopamine shoots off every time you see them, text them, or smell their hoodie. When the relationship ends, your brain screams, “Where’s my reward hit?!” You’re not just sad—you’re chemically crashing.
  2. Narrative Collapse
    The hippocampus (your memory maestro) had been storing all the “evidence” of your relationship story: first kiss, shared playlists, private jokes about seagulls. When you realise half of it was based on a false version of them, your brain has to do a factory recall on the entire narrative. This is exhausting.
  3. Identity Earthquake
    Relationships are co-written scripts. You played “the partner” opposite their role. But when you realise they weren’t who they said they were, your own role feels shaky. “If I didn’t know them, do I even know myself?” asks your amygdala while it panics in the corner.

Healing: From Ghost-Love to Self-Love

Here’s the hopeful bit: neuroscience also tells us the brain is ridiculously good at rewiring. It’s called neuroplasticity, and it means healing is not only possible—it’s inevitable if you give it a little nudge.

  1. Reality Recalibration
    Write down what you know was real (your feelings, your growth, your kindness). Then write what was illusion. Separating the two gives the hippocampus a filing system that reduces confusion.
  2. Dopamine Detox and Rebuild
    Your reward system needs new hits. Exercise, learning something new, even laughing at cat videos all reintroduce dopamine in healthy ways. Your brain can’t tell if it’s “love” dopamine or “I just learned how to make focaccia” dopamine. It just knows it’s happy.
  3. Compassionate Reframe
    Instead of beating yourself up for “falling for the illusion,” remember: your brain was doing its job. Humans evolved to bond. Sometimes, that means the Photoshop filter was on too strong. Empathy towards yourself is the reset button.
  4. New Scripts, New Roles
    Channel your prefrontal cortex to write fresh stories. Maybe you’re “the independent adventurer,” or “the person who takes salsa lessons on Tuesdays.” Re-authoring your role stabilises identity and reduces that “who even am I” feeling.

Final Note: You’re Not Broken, Your Brain Is Just Human

Realising the person you loved never existed is brutal. It’s like showing up to Hogwarts only to find out it’s just a slightly damp train station. But here’s the secret: your love was real. Your capacity to feel, imagine, and invest in someone is proof of your brain’s brilliance, not its weakness.

And with time, your neurons will rewire, your narrative will rebuild, and you’ll fall in love again—hopefully with someone less phantom-y and more three-dimensional.

One response to “When the Breakup Hits Twice: Realising You Loved Someone Who Never Existed”

  1. A WordPress Commenter Avatar

    Hi, this is a comment.
    To get started with moderating, editing, and deleting comments, please visit the Comments screen in the dashboard.
    Commenter avatars come from Gravatar.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×